By and large he succeeded, and nowadays everything is welltempered, in fact, equal temperament, a slightly more advanced specific welltempered tuning system that takes the idea to its most functional and efficient solution, and to our ears older tuning systems just sound horrible and out of tune. Welltempered definition is properly constituted physically. There is actually a lot of history found in this book, and the well tempered city was a far more fascinating read than i had assumed when reading the title and description. The welltempered tune is devoted to promoting the fine craft of piano tuning in madison, alabama and surrounding areas. The welltempered clavier wikipedia republished wiki 2. The chromatic notes in meantone tuning really jump out and grab the attention, while the equal temperament version is much more even. Internal evidence for this may be seen in the fact that in book 1 bach. The welltempered clavier, bwv 846893, is a collection of two series of preludes and fugues in all major and minor keys, composed for solo keyboard by johann sebastian bach. A classroom essential and an invaluable reference, the arithmetic of listening offers beginners the grounding in music theory necessary to find their. The welltempered clavier is generally regarded as one of the most influential works in the history of western classical music. Free sheet music for the complete 48 preludes and fugues of the well tempered clavier by j. The phrase well tempered was first used by the german tuner werckmeister in 1691 to describe a method of tuning that removed the wolves heard in previous tuning methods. Apart from the early versions of several preludes included in w. The parameters in the p5 tuning can be obtained from a table similar to that shown above by constructing a scale from a440 using a multiplier of 1.
Some scholars believe that bach was an advocate on equal. The well tempered clavier, or preludes and fugues in all the tones and semitones, both with the major third or ut, re, mi and with the minor. In bachs time clavier was a generic name indicating a variety of keyboard instruments, most a harpsichord or clavichord but not excluding an organ either. He gave the title to abook of preludes and fugues in all 24 major and minor keys, dated 1722, composed for the profit and use of musical youth desirous of learning, and especially for the pastime of those already skilled in this study. How equal temperament ruined harmony and why you should. Andras schiff prom 2018 well tempered clavier book ii c. The welltempered fifths are practically all equal, being reduced by 15 pythagorean comma, i. The welltempered clavier, book 1 bwv 846869 the welltempered clavier 1 is a collection of educational pieces with exceptionally high artistic contents. The first book of the welltempered clavier was composed in the early 1720s, with bachs autograph dated 1722. Thanks to how equal temperament ruined harmony, we may soon be able to hear for ourselves what beethoven really meant when he called b minor black wall street journal. The welltempered clavier, bwv 846893, collection of 48 preludes and fugues by johann sebastian bach, published in two books 1722 and 1742. Introduction bachs musical temperament comprises within its circle 5 well tempered fifths and 7 perfect fifths.
Bach wrote the preludes and fugues of the welltempered. The introduction put me off a bit, as it seemed like it was going to be way too deep for my understanding of both cities and music yes, music. The goal of his new tuning method was to provide a practical organization of the tone system within the twelve steps of an octave so that impeccable performance. The freelancestar once again, author and translator alike, have magically strung a beautiful piece of writing together. Each book contains 24 relatively free, improvisatory preludes, each of which precedes a fugue. Happy 250th, well tempered clavier, book i the new york. A project from the 2012 book, doomsday knits, which was recently reissued. The history of musical temperament and pitch before 1750.
Bachs klavierbuchlein 1720 there is an almost complete collection of prelude and fughetta versions predating the 1722 autograph, known from a later copy by an unidentified scribe. These preludefugue pairs cycle through all 24 possible major and minor tona. Bach composed his well tempered clavier to promote equal temperamentet. Well temperament also good temperament, circular or circulating temperament is a type of tempered tuning described in 20thcentury music theory. Ranking of difficulty of well tempered clavier preludes.
It was discovered by slightly cheating the distance between pitches that the keyboard could be adjusted to be in tune for all keys. I would appreciate any info on ranking of the difficulty of the preludes in the well tempered clavier. The definition in my book, bach to bernstein by lynn hartingware says that equal temperament was developed as a tuning adjustment to the keyboard that enabled it to play in all keys. Welltempered definition of welltempered by merriamwebster. The well tempered city is a deeply felt and wideranging book by jonathan f.
Under the old tuning, an organ made harmonious and attractive music. But history is filled with different ways that a scale could be tuned. The welltempered clavier is a collection of two books of keyboard music. Yet in western circles, no other musical issue is so ignored, so taken for granted, so shoved into the corners of musical discourse. The welltempered clavier contemporary classical wiki. Its doubtful that bachs well tempered tuning was an exact match to the equal tempered tuning that eventually became the accepted standard. Contrary to what youve been taught, bach did not compose the well tempered clavier to promote the equal tempered tuning system. The werkmeister tunings are the most well known of this sort. Well temperament is a type of tempered tuning described in 20thcentury music theory. Trevor stephenson performs bachs c major prelude from book i of the welltempered clavier.
Begun in 1964, young has never considered the composition or performance finished, and he has performed incarnations of it several times since its debut in 1974. An acoustic piano becomes something truly special when it is well tuned. In france, meantone tuning was the standard until the 1750s, and in england, meantone was the standard until the 1850s. Its my impression that many pipe organs are still tuned in this manner so that is the context youll often hear it in, due to way that the sustained nature of the notes works with the common repertoire.
Duffin presents a serious and well argued case goldberg magazine that should. What is the significance of the welltempered clavier. Just as with every other musical instrument, poor tuning is unacceptable. Second, 22 years separate the wtcs two books, and there are significant differences between them. Rose makes a creative effort to give some truly simple advice to mayors, urban leaders, and citybuilders. Equal temperament contrary to what youve been taught, bach did not compose the well tempered clavier to promote the equal tempered tuning system. Barbour traces the history of tuning and temperament, from pythagoras to our modern age of equal temperament, giving detailed mathematical descriptions of various mean. Tuning is the secret lens through which the history of music falls into focus, says kyle gann. An introduction to historical tunings by kyle gann.
World heritage encyclopedia, the aggregation of the largest online. The guardian described the piece as one of the great achievements of 20thcentury music. Equal temperament actually did not come into use until the 20th century. Bachs seminal work the welltempered clavier showcases an ability that. In 1879, william pole wrote in his book the philosophy of music, the modern practice of tuning all organs to equal temperament has been a fearful detriment to their quality of tone. I know there have been discussions of ranking the difficulty of the well tempered clavier for example, bartok, but it is my understanding that those take into account the fugues as well. The term is modeled on the german word wohltemperiert. Roses nonstop tour of the cityan in depth account of its history, theory, and practiceis exhilarating and complete, wherein compassion, bachs the welltempered clavier, and contemporary scientific thinking finally come to rest together.
Bach, c major prelude wtc i, welltemperament, trevor. The equal tempered system uses a constant frequency multiple between the notes of the chromatic scale. Unlike a keyboard instrument, the violin is not restricted to playing in any fixed temperament, except for the tuning of the open strings. He did, however, write the 48 pieces a prelude and fugue in each of the 12 minor and major keys on a welltempered instrument one whose tuning had been tweaked to allow for playing in all of the keys, c major being the most in tune incidentally. Like the previous book, the art of hearing heartbeats, the sequel is beautifully writtenin this series, the mystical elements are as important as the mundanemany readers will find a welltempered heart incredibly beautiful and moving. Discoverability and providence grant from the templeton foundation. In the german of bachs time clavier was a generic name indicating a variety of keyboard instruments, most typically a harpsichord or clavichord but not excluding an organ either. Its subtitle what modern science, ancient civilizations, and human nature teach us about the future of urban life offers a hint of the book s depth and complexity. I will have my piano tuned to thomas youngs 1799 well temperament. Ross duffin has written an engaging, densely argued and robust demolition of the commonly held idea that equal temperament triumphed in the time of bachs well tempered clavier and has been the one true tuning ever since. In bachs time clavier was a generic name indicating a variety of keyboard instruments, most typically a harpsichord or clavichord but not excluding an organ either the modern german spelling for the collection is. If you know how to understand it and use it, it can be extremely helpful, but may be a tad overwhelming to the novice. The welltempered city was a far more fascinating read than i had assumed when reading the title and description. I received a copy of this book for free through a goodreads first reads giveaway.
Bachs motivation for composing the wtc was to demonstrate the feasability of composing in well temperament and to demostrate the varying key. The welltempered city, winner of the 2017 prose award for outstanding scholarly work by a trade publisher. From all the works written in the baroque era, no other work has been so well cherished, frequently performed and. A manuscript of the fugue in ab minor from the well tempered clavier book ii. Rose, planner, developer, and longtime new urbanist. Some 40 minutes longer in duration than book i, the added bulk of book ii is to be found. A welltempered heart touches the reader on many levels. The introduction put me off a bit, as it seemed like it was going to be way too deep for. Im studying music history rcm history 1 by myself and im confused about the definition of equal temperament and how it differs from well temperament in the baroque era.
It explores the intricacies of each of the 12 major and 12 minor keys and constitutes the largestscale and mostinfluential undertaking for solo keyboard of the baroque era. The welltempered clavier, bwv 846893, is a collection of two sets of preludes and fugues in all 24 major and minor keys, composed for solo keyboard by johann sebastian bach. The equal tempered scale was developed for keyboard instruments, such as the piano, so that they could be played equally well or badly in any key. When we follow the trail of the words historical significance, we ultimately arrive at the history of tuning methods. Books such as groves music dictionary which contain incorrect information regarding bachs. To play the welltempered clavier on an instrument tuned in equal. The term well tempered is generally used for what you refer to in the end. Composition history, later significance and influence, what tuning did bach intend. Templeton foundation grant to finish the welltempered universe. Bachs welltempered clavier was, among many tuning and temperament. Bach wrote the welltempered clavier in the eighteenth century, and there is much debate on what was meant by well tempered. It was, to be sure, tuned in a way that is more similar to the equal temperament system. In practice, individual notes are tempered according to the musical context, often by much more than the difference between a welltemperament and equal temperament.
817 420 1551 1364 1545 1339 511 803 404 631 1453 526 58 1507 1172 185 788 112 394 812 12 41 172 461 406 1016 1421 1098 697 837 1039 1611 579 846 1613 208 996 160 776 894 996 110 78 150 431 219